Is all property acquired during marriage necessarily considered the joint property of the spouses? Can one spouse claim exclusive ownership of an entire apartment if it was purchased solely with that spouse’s own funds? And what legal significance does the source of the funds used to acquire the property have?
These questions frequently arise in judicial disputes concerning divorce, division of property, and recognition of ownership rights.
Although the law establishes a presumption of joint ownership of property acquired during marriage, the case law of the Court of Cassation of the Republic of Armenia demonstrates that the timing of the acquisition is not always the sole determining factor.
Of particular importance is the decision of the Court of Cassation of the Republic of Armenia dated June 26, 2025, in Case No. ԵԴ/36794/02/19, which further developed the legal approach to determining the status of property acquired using one spouse’s separate funds.
1. What Constitutes Joint Property of Spouses?
Pursuant to Article 201(1) of the Civil Code of the Republic of Armenia, property acquired by spouses during marriage constitutes their joint property unless otherwise provided by law or by an agreement concluded between them.
This provision is based on the presumption of joint ownership.
Accordingly, an apartment, residential house, land plot, vehicle, or other property acquired during marriage is, as a general rule, considered the joint property of both spouses.
In this regard, the following circumstances are not, in themselves, decisive:
-
which spouse is registered as the owner of the property;
-
which spouse entered into the sale and purchase agreement;
-
which spouse actually made the payment;
-
which spouse earned income from employment or entrepreneurial activities.
Consequently, the fact that an apartment is registered solely in the name of the husband or wife does not necessarily mean that the other spouse has no ownership rights in respect of that property.
However, the presumption of joint ownership is not absolute.
2. What Property Is Considered the Separate Property of a Spouse?
Article 201(2) of the Civil Code of the Republic of Armenia provides exceptions to the general rule of joint ownership.
In particular, the following constitutes a spouse’s separate property:
-
property owned by that spouse before marriage;
-
property received by that spouse as a gift during marriage;
-
property inherited by that spouse during marriage.
For example, if one spouse owned an apartment before marriage, that apartment does not automatically become the joint property of the spouses upon marriage.
The same principle applies where one spouse receives an apartment as a gift or through inheritance during marriage.
But what happens when separate property is sold and the proceeds are used to purchase another apartment during marriage?
The Court of Cassation of the Republic of Armenia specifically addressed this issue in its 2025 decision.
3. The Court of Cassation’s Important 2025 Legal Position: New Property Acquired with Separate Funds Does Not Necessarily Become Joint Property
In its decision dated June 26, 2025, in Case No. ԵԴ/36794/02/19, the Court of Cassation of the Republic of Armenia examined the legal status of property acquired during marriage using one spouse’s separate funds.
In doing so, the Court of Cassation further developed the legal interpretation concerning the preservation of separate ownership.
The central principle underlying the Court’s position is that acquiring new property with proceeds from the sale of property constituting one spouse’s separate property does not, in itself, alter the separate nature of the ownership rights.
Where new property is acquired exclusively with such separate funds, its status as separate property may be preserved, notwithstanding the fact that the new property was acquired during marriage.
The Court of Cassation also emphasized the importance of protecting the right to property guaranteed under Article 60 of the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia. It noted that converting separate property into joint property without a proper legal basis prescribed by law may result in a disproportionate restriction of property rights.
Thus, the 2025 decision emphasizes that, in certain circumstances, it is necessary to establish not only when the property was acquired but also the legal origin of the funds used for its acquisition.
At the same time, it should be noted that the Court of Cassation did not finally determine that the disputed property belonged exclusively to the defendant. Instead, the Court overturned the decision of the Court of Appeal and remitted the case for a new examination to assess the relevant factual circumstances.
4. If an Apartment Is Purchased Solely with Money Earned by One Spouse, Is It Considered That Spouse’s Separate Property?
In practice, situations frequently arise where one spouse pays the entire purchase price of an apartment acquired during marriage.
For example, the husband may engage in entrepreneurial activities, earn income, and use that income to purchase an apartment, while the other spouse makes no direct financial contribution towards the acquisition.
Can the spouse who paid the full purchase price demand that the apartment be recognized as their exclusive property?
The mere fact that payment was made by one spouse is insufficient to substantiate such a claim.
A distinction must be drawn between property acquired using income earned by one spouse through employment or entrepreneurial activities during marriage and property acquired using proceeds from the disposal of assets constituting that spouse’s separate property.
In the first situation, the general presumption of joint ownership applies. In the second, provided that the relevant facts are established by evidence, the legal position adopted by the Court of Cassation in 2025 concerning the preservation of separate ownership may apply.
Consequently, the fact that one spouse did not work or made no direct financial contribution towards acquiring the property does not, in itself, exclude joint ownership rights.
5. Can a Spouse Who Made a Substantial Financial Contribution Claim a Larger Share of the Property?
Pursuant to Article 199(2) of the Civil Code of the Republic of Armenia, when dividing common property or allocating a share from it, the shares of participants in joint ownership are presumed equal unless otherwise provided by law or by agreement between the participants.
It follows that equal shares constitute the starting point when dividing spouses’ joint property.
For example, if an apartment was purchased for AMD 60 million and one spouse claims to have personally contributed AMD 50 million, it is necessary to establish the legal nature of the funds contributed.
If those funds form part of the common assets accumulated during marriage, the fact that payment was made by only one spouse does not, in itself, entitle that spouse to a larger share of the apartment.
The situation is different where it is proven that the funds contributed constituted the separate property of one spouse.
In such circumstances, a legal dispute may arise concerning whether the property should be recognized, in whole or in the relevant part, as the separate property of that spouse. The resolution of such a dispute depends on the facts of the case, the origin of the funds used, and the evidence presented.
However, it is important to emphasize that the Court of Cassation’s decision of June 26, 2025, in Case No. ԵԴ/36794/02/19 does not expressly establish a general rule requiring spouses’ ownership shares to be determined in proportion to their respective percentage contributions.
6. When Can Separate Property Become Joint Property? The Legal Significance of Substantial Investments
The legislation also provides for the reverse situation.
Under Article 201(4) of the Civil Code of the Republic of Armenia, property belonging separately to either spouse may be recognized as their joint property if, during marriage, investments were made using common property or the separate property of the other spouse, resulting in a substantial increase in the value of that property.
Such investments may include:
-
major repairs;
-
reconstruction;
-
refurbishment or re-equipment;
-
other works that significantly increase the value of the property.
An important legal position on this issue was established by the Court of Cassation of the Republic of Armenia in its decision dated December 26, 2013, in Case No. ԿԴ1/0415/02/11.
The Court of Cassation clarified that three conditions must be established simultaneously for one spouse’s separate property to be recognized as joint property.
First — the existence of investments. It must be established that, during marriage, relevant investments were made using common property or the separate property of the other spouse.
Second — a substantial increase in the property’s value. It must be established that the work performed actually resulted in a significant increase in the property’s value.
Third — a causal connection. It must be proven that the increase in the property’s value resulted specifically from those investments.
The Court of Cassation further clarified that investments do not necessarily have to be monetary. They may take the form of the provision of materials or the personal labor of a spouse.
At the same time, the mere fact that renovations were carried out is insufficient. It is necessary to assess the market value of the property before and after the investments and determine the actual cause of any increase in value.
For example, if the market value of an apartment increases solely due to a general rise in real estate prices, that circumstance alone does not establish that the property’s value increased substantially as a result of investments made by a spouse.
7. How Can It Be Proven That Property Was Acquired Using Separate Funds?
In property disputes between spouses, not only the arguments presented by the parties but also the evidence supporting those arguments are of decisive importance.
In particular, the following documents and evidence may be relevant in establishing that property was acquired using separate funds:
-
documents confirming ownership of previously held property;
-
documents evidencing gifts or inheritance;
-
the sale and purchase agreement relating to previously owned property;
-
bank transfer records and account statements;
-
the sale and purchase agreement for the newly acquired property;
-
payment documents;
-
other evidence establishing the movement of funds and the chronology of transactions.
It is necessary to establish both a factual and legal connection between the funds constituting one spouse’s separate property and the acquisition of the new property.
For example, where a spouse sells an apartment received through inheritance, deposits the sale proceeds into a bank account, and subsequently uses those same funds to acquire a new apartment, the documented sequence of transactions may be of substantial importance in determining the legal status of the newly acquired property.
Conversely, where it is impossible to establish the precise source of the funds used to acquire the property, substantiating a claim that the property constitutes separate property may become difficult.
8. Development of the Court of Cassation’s Precedential Legal Positions on Joint Property of Spouses
The case law of the Court of Cassation of the Republic of Armenia demonstrates that both the presumption of joint ownership and the statutory exceptions to that presumption are important when assessing the legal status of spouses’ property.
In particular:
In its decision dated June 1, 2007, in Case No. 3-415(ՎԴ), the Court of Cassation emphasized the presumption of joint ownership of property acquired during marriage, regardless of which spouse was registered as the owner or whose funds were used for the acquisition.
In its decision dated December 26, 2013, in Case No. ԿԴ1/0415/02/11, the Court provided a detailed interpretation of the conditions under which substantial investments may justify recognizing one spouse’s separate property as joint property.
In its decision dated February 4, 2020, in Case No. ԵԱՔԴ/2451/02/16, the Court reaffirmed the legal approaches concerning joint ownership of property acquired during marriage, as well as the significance of the principle of equal shares when dividing common property.
In its decision dated June 26, 2025, in Case No. ԵԴ/36794/02/19, the Court of Cassation further developed its approach to the transformation of separate property, emphasizing the continuity of separate ownership rights and the origin of the funds used to acquire property.
Thus, the development of judicial practice has increasingly highlighted the need to assess the specific factual circumstances when determining ownership rights over property acquired during marriage.
Conclusion
As a general rule, property acquired during marriage is considered the joint property of the spouses. However, this rule is subject to exceptions, the applicability of which depends on the origin of the property, the source of funds used for its acquisition, and other circumstances of the case.
The Court of Cassation’s decision of June 26, 2025, is particularly significant in cases where one spouse acquires new property using funds constituting that spouse’s separate property.
At the same time, it is essential to distinguish proceeds derived from the sale of separate property from income earned through employment or entrepreneurial activities during marriage.
Consequently, the mere fact that property was acquired during marriage does not invariably establish joint ownership, just as payment of the entire purchase price by one spouse does not necessarily establish that spouse’s exclusive ownership rights.
In each case, it is necessary to assess the legal grounds for acquiring the property, the sources of financing, the investments made, and the supporting evidence.
In disputes concerning the division of spouses’ joint property, recognition of separate ownership rights, or the legal significance of investments, it is essential to formulate the claim correctly and identify the appropriate legal grounds on which it should be based.